Quick Verdict
The Rawlings Pro Preferred is a genuine pro-quality glove that competes directly with Heart of the Hide. The Kip leather is lighter, breaks in faster, and has a finer grain texture — qualities that middle infielders and speed-oriented players prefer. For outfielders and corner players who want maximum durability under heavy use, HOH's thicker steer hide edges ahead. At similar pricing ($20-50 difference), this is a preference decision rather than a quality tiering decision.
Check Price on Amazon ↗Specifications
| Leather Grade | Top 5% Kip leather (calfskin) |
| Lining | Sheepskin-lined fingers |
| Padding | Moldable padding |
| Welting | Dual welting |
| Infield Sizes | 11.25", 11.5", 11.75" |
| Outfield Sizes | 12", 12.75" |
| Break-in % | ~70% factory (faster than HOH) |
| Weight feel | Lighter than HOH |
| Price Range | $230–$350 |
Kip Leather vs Heart of the Hide: The Key Difference
Heart of the Hide uses mature steer hide — thicker, denser fiber structure, heavier per square inch. This thickness provides exceptional durability and structural rigidity: a HOH glove maintains its pocket shape under heavy use, resisting deformation over years of intense play. The tradeoff is weight and break-in time — steer hide is simply heavier and more stiff initially.
Kip leather (used in Pro Preferred) is calfskin — from younger animals, it has a finer grain structure, lower mass per unit area, and more natural suppleness than mature steer hide. The Pro Preferred is measurably lighter than equivalent HOH models — roughly 10-20% lighter depending on size. This weight difference matters for middle infielders who prize quick hand transfer and glove-to-throwing-hand exchange speed.
Break-in: Pro Preferred arrives at ~70% factory-broken (vs ~60% for HOH). Both require player work to develop the perfect pocket, but Pro Preferred gets there 1-2 weeks faster. For players who need a competition-ready glove quickly or who prefer softer leather feel from the start, this matters.
Durability: HOH's thicker structure means it's more resistant to the pocket collapsing under heavy use — a consideration for high-volume catchers and corner outfielders. Pro Preferred, while excellent quality, may show wear patterns slightly earlier under the same intensive use. For the average competitive player, this difference manifests over 5-8+ years of daily use — well beyond the practical decision horizon for most glove purchases.
Head-to-Head: Pro Preferred vs Heart of the Hide
| Feature | Pro Preferred (Kip) | Heart of the Hide (Steer) |
|---|---|---|
| Leather type | Kip (calfskin) | Steer hide (mature) |
| Weight | Lighter | Heavier |
| Break-in time | Faster (~2 weeks) | Longer (~3-4 weeks) |
| Long-term durability | Excellent | Superior |
| Grain texture | Finer grain | Coarser grain |
| Shock absorption | Good | Better (zero-shock pad) |
| Best position | 2B, SS, pitchers | All positions, OF, 3B, C |
| Price range | $230–350 | $250–380 |
Pros and Cons
Pros
- ✓ Lighter than HOH — faster hand exchange
- ✓ Finer Kip grain — smooth, premium feel
- ✓ Faster break-in (~70% factory)
- ✓ Sheepskin-lined fingers for comfort
- ✓ Dual welting for structural longevity
- ✓ Available in smaller infield sizes (11.25")
Cons
- − Slightly less long-term durability than HOH steer hide
- − No zero-shock palm pad (HOH advantage)
- − Still $230-350 — significant investment
- − Slightly fewer size/web options than HOH line
Who Should Buy Pro Preferred?
As an Amazon Associate, RawlingsReview.com earns from qualifying purchases.